Living during the great upheaval that followed the decline of the Roman Empire, Benedict of Nursia (480–547 AD) struggled with the lack of Christlike character in monks he derogatorily called “gyrovagues.” These monks would enter a monastery, stay for a few days, eat their fill, and then move on at the first sign of relational tension, hard work or boredom.
Benedict wisely understood that spiritual maturity would be impossible if monks could change their environments so easily. Consequently, he introduced a very practical solution: a new order of monks committed to the vows of stability, fidelity, and obedience. Meant to work synergistically, these ancient vows are still helpful for disciples who hope to be truly transformed into the image of Christ.
Fidelity Defined
Benedict’s second vow, conversatio morum (conversion of life), is a complex Latin term that is best translated as fidelity to a monastic way of life. Fidelity is an old-fashioned term that means remaining faithful to something or someone. It is closely related to the concepts of loyalty, commitment, and allegiance. Fidelity means remaining dedicated or devoted to something over the long haul.
Central to this vow is a commitment to life-long spiritual growth and personal transformation. Benedict understood that a call to Christlikeness requires a daily mixture of God’s grace and human effort. This attitude is seen in his emphasis on ora et labora (pray and work) as foundational to Benedictine monastic life.
Why Fidelity Is Important Today
The Evangelical church has long emphasized the Good News, which includes salvation through Jesus Christ and a personal conversion experience, commonly referred to as being “born again.” This focus on conversion has contributed to countless people throughout the world choosing to follow Jesus. Praise God for that!
At the same time, this singular focus on conversion can cast a couple of shadows in terms of spiritual formation.
First, an emphasis on conversion often leads to a “one-and-done” perspective of following Jesus. Rather than understanding “praying the prayer” or being “born again” as first steps in a life-long journey, they are often viewed as the sum-total of what it means to be a Christian. As a result, ongoing transformation has become optional, or set is aside all together.
Second, the emphasis on “being saved” which comes about “by grace alone and not by works”1 can lead to skepticism about human effort. It is right to be concerned that adding works to salvation might diminish what Jesus accomplished on the cross. However, this concern about “grace and not works” can also lead to believers avoiding the personal effort necessary for ongoing transformation.
Healthy Spiritual Formation
Benedict’s vow of fidelity addresses these concerns. First, it reminds us that both initial conversion and conversatio morum, or conversion of life, are necessary for healthy spiritual formation. Conversion begins the process and conversatio morum continues that process for the rest of a person’s life.
Putting effort towards ongoing transformation is an important response to the unearned grace of salvation. Without it, maturity in Christ will be elusive.
Second, much as was the case with Jesus’ brother James,2 Bendict’s call to fidelity acknowledges that God’s grace and human effort are necessary for lifelong transformation. As Dallas Willard says, “Grace is not opposed to effort, it is opposed to earning!”3
Putting effort towards ongoing transformation is an important response to the unearned grace of salvation. Without it, maturity in Christ will be elusive. Unfortunately, we do not simply drift towards Christlikeness.
A Practical Way to Engage
At Monte Vista Chapel, we’ve developed a practical way to engage daily with Benedict’s vow of fidelity: It is the simple process of observation, invitation, and cooperation, or OIC for short. (It also sounds like “Oh, I see!” which makes it easy to remember!) I’ll unpack it below.
Knowing God’s Love
As with all things formational, the process must begin with God’s love. As mentioned above, ongoing transformation is never an attempt to earn God’s favor. Rather, it is a response to knowing that God fully loves you. For many, accepting this reality is difficult, which is why Benedict’s guiding rule was “prefer nothing to the love of Christ.” For Benedict, as for most monastic communities, the spiritual journey is, at its core, a school of divine love.
If truly knowing God’s love is a struggle for you, make this your number one priority.

Start by asking God to show you the depth of his love for you. Then read and reflect on Scriptures such as the parable of the Prodigal Son in Luke 15:11–32 and Paul’s prayer in Ephesians 3:14–19. Read the Gospels, especially John, listening for God’s love for you in and through Jesus. You may also find encouragement in books like Abba’s Child by Brennan Manning, Life of the Beloved by Henri Nouwen, and Surrender to Love by David Benner.
A good spiritual director can help you encounter God’s love in a personal way too. Experiencing and returning to God’s love fuels conversatio morum—without it, you’ll make little progress.
Observe Your Life
From a foundation of God’s love, the next movement in the process is observation.
Learn to see your everyday life as the “school” God enrolled you in to become more like Jesus. Your job is to prayerfully pay attention to your life and notice where you fall short of Christlikeness.
For example: If you react in anger when someone cuts you off in traffic, you may need to work on patience or kindness. If you feel contempt or disregard toward someone you know, you may need to work on forgiveness. If you find yourself consistently anxious or reactive, you may need to work on trusting God amidst your fear. If you feel resistance when God points out an area for growth, you may need to work on surrender. (I could go on, but you get the idea.)
When you first start seeing your life through this lens, it can feel overwhelming. There’s so much to change. But don’t despair!
God isn’t shocked, surprised, or disappointed in you for any of it. In fact, God has known about these things long before you did . . . and he still fully loves you! God brings them to light so he can set you free.
An Invitation to Grow
The next movement is invitation. Because God knows you so well, he knows the specific steps you need to take to become like Jesus, and in his grace, he knows when you’re ready to take them. Your job is to prayerfully discern where God is inviting you to grow.
Often, you’ll find God’s invitation points to the “loudest” issue you’ve been observing in your life. For example, if you keep running into the person you’re struggling to forgive, God may well be asking you to work on that area.
Right now, I’m experiencing an uncharacteristic bout of anxiety, and I’ve discerned that God is inviting me to grow my trust and tend to my fear.
Other times, God may invite you to work on what seem like lesser issues, because you’re not yet ready or willing to put in the intentional effort the louder areas demand. Since formation doesn’t happen overnight, discerning God’s invitation to one specific area gives you permission to spend real time and energy going deep on a single issue, rather than skimming the surface of many.
Cooperate with God
Once you sense God’s invitation, it’s time for the final movement: cooperation.
It helps to remember Dallas Willard’s words again—God’s grace opposes earning, not effort, so each of us plays an active role in becoming more like Jesus. Another acronym, VIM (vision, intention, means), can help us cooperate with God.
Vision of Flourishing
First, prayerfully ask God for a vision of what it might look and feel like to live out Jesus’ model. Ask God to teach you in the specific area that you’ve identified needs work.
For example, if you’ve observed a need to forgive more freely, picture how you’d think, feel, and act if you were free from the anger, contempt, or hatred that a lack of forgiveness breeds. Consider how you might sleep better, how your body might relax, and how you’d stop avoiding places where you might run into the person you can’t forgive. Sit with the expansive freedom of loving freely, rather than the soul-crushing weight of unforgiveness.
An Intention to Change
Once you have the vision for a flourishing life, move toward intention.
Again, let’s hold forgiveness as the example: You can’t just “flip a switch” to make forgiveness happen. What you can do is set your will toward the vision of becoming a forgiving person. You can decide, even before you feel like it, to become someone who experiences the freedom of forgiveness.
That act of intention awakens one of the most powerful motivators God gave you: desire. Once you feel a genuine desire to become a forgiving person, you’ll naturally start seeking the means to get there.
The Means for Change
The means might include prayer, study, reading, conversations with people who’ve learned to forgive, or working with a counselor or spiritual director. People often start the whole process by hunting for the right means to change. But VIM suggests that fixating on means too early doesn’t help. Once you hold a clear vision and sincerely intend to grow in Christlikeness in a specific area, then you can rest assured that the Holy Spirit will supply whatever internal and external means you need.
A Final Word of Encouragement
If Christians are going to actually reflect Jesus and not simply claim his name, a commitment to the Benedictine vow of fidelity, or conversatio morum, is critical. While I believe this to my core, I also understand that always being “in process” can feel unsettling. So, I’ll leave you with the encouraging and impactful words of Pierre Teilhard de Chardin:4
Above all, trust in the slow work of God.5
May it be so.
Article by Ken Van Vliet.
- Ephesians 2:8–9 ↩︎
- James 2:18 ↩︎
- Dallas Willard, The Great Omission: Reclaiming Jesus’s Essential Teachings on Discipleship, (San Franscisco: HarperOne, 2006). ↩︎
- Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, “Patient Trust,” in Hearts on Fire: Praying with Jesuits, ed. Michael Harter (Chicago: Loyola Press, 2005). ↩︎
- Read the whole poem here: https://www.ignatianspirituality.com/prayer-of-theilhard-de-chardin. ↩︎